I’m having some issues with a 2-month old Neo 2T (I decided to switch to Tacx after 3 faulty Wahoo KICKRs)
Whenever I do a workout in ERG mode in the 36 in front, I feel very strong vibrations through the pedal cranks, no matter which cog in the back and no matter the cadence.
Some other clues:
The issue becomes less noticeable when moving to the 52 in front, probably because the flywheel spins faster. However, this significantly increases the vibration from the turbo which resonates badly in the wooden floor of our flat.
Both my girlfriend and I have a Cannondale SuperSix Evo with ultegra and disk brakes. The issue is much more noticeable and annoying on my bike, but we can also feel it on my girlfriend’s bike.
Indexing should be ok.
I cleaned and lubed the chain last weekend, but unfortunately nothing changed.
From the research I gathered, the issue could be explained by some of the following
Free-hub bearings
Old chain/new cassette: I did a bike service mid-January and I got a new Shimano HG-X11 chain. I bought a new ultegra 11-32 cassette for the trainer and since then I rode ~2000km on it. I checked the chain wear with a wear meter and it doesn’t look too bad.
Bearings in bottom bracket: even if this should have happened between January and now.
Bent rear derailleur: when I tighten the skewer, the frame compresses and the derailleur moves quite a bit. I’m wondering if it’s also changing its angle…
Something wrong with the turbo itself: I saw quite a few people complaining about this same issue on the Tacx Owners facebook group, so it might well be a firmware issue. This wouldn’t be too weird also considering that my Neo 2T reports 30/40W less than my previous Wahoo Kickrs (I don’t have a power meter to do a proper comparison, but my FTP dropped from 296W in December on the Kickr to 262W in February on the Neo2T after having done 8 weeks of Trainerroad half-distance triathlon base program… and FTP doesn’t go down when training consistently on Trainerroad )
Has anyone had this same issue and found a solution?
What do you mean by “strong vibrations”? Like… if you were in an apartment would it annoy your downstairs neighbour? Sometimes with Neo you can feel the steps in the resistance unit as it is basically a large stepper motor.
It feels like the road feel option of the Neo2T was on and riding on gravel. Clearly, I turned the road feel off from the Tacx utility app and I doubt that TR would use that feature anyway.
It feels like a continuous grinding in the pedal cranks. There’s no significant sounds from the trainer, therefore I don’t think my issue is related to the “sawbone” issue I saw mentioned online.
We can definitely feel the vibration/grinding in the wooden floor, even in the adjacent rooms.
As a side note, when doing a workout in ERG mode on TrainerRoad I normally use a 36-21 or 36-19.
I don’t think it’s the virtual wheel slip, as the griding/vibration is continuous throughout the pedal stroke. when doing a workout in ERG mode on TrainerRoad I normally use a 36-21 or 36-19, and I can feel the vibration during the warmup when spinning at 150W and 85/90rpm. From what I read online, these are not the conditions when the virtual wheel slip typically happens (if it even happens on a Neo 2T).
Adding in my recent experience. I recently switched from a Kickr18 to the Neo 2T. For the most part I am happy with the unit. Definitely quieter than the Kickr (pre-knocking noise too!). I have noticed some dropouts in TR when running TR via ANT+ alongside running Zwift via BT, although this does seem to be related to on-screen data as there is no drop in resistance and TR didn’t notice any official dropout in my data.
Biggest issue I have had though is that occasionally (1-2x per week) my resistance will lock up for no reason. This isn’t a virtual slip issue as it is not occurring when trying to mash the power/torque. Rather I can be spinning along at SS around 90 cadence and then the pedals just stop going. I typically backpedal for about 5 seconds and then get going again at the target power (I’m running ERG). I chatted with the Garmin folks today and they suggested this was a known software issue and that it is being worked on. I have switched to now running TR via BT, so hoping that helps and also solves the data blank/dropout issue.
Fingers crossed the lockup doesn’t happen on my next Ramp Test!
I remember having those high torque locks with my NEO 1, I solved this issue by using the Tacx Ant+ antenna, also the TR control was on point since then. Nowadays, I’m using the same antenna to connect TR with my Neo 2T, alongside with Zwift connected via Bluetooth. No dropouts whatsoever, maybe you’ll find something useful regarding those here or here
Unfortunately my 2T died after five minutes use from new. Have been in touch with others with the same problem. Garmin have been slow to respond with anything useful and its a big outlay so first impressions are not great! I’ll post again here with any progress on this.
I have the latest firmware on both, performed zero offset on the assiomas, and I see, in high power intervals (well, high for me), the assiomas read 10 to 15 watts higher than what the Neo 2T is reading.
It’s got me to the point that I have done the warm up with the Neo controlling it, but after the first real interval I switch back to the Assiomas controlling the trainer power.
How high is high power? Even if it’s 300W, then a 15W delta is still only a 5% difference - probably within the margin of error of each of the Neo and the Assiomas?
I’ve been using TR for a number of years using a set up of Stages Power meter + Elite Turbo Muin which has worked really well for me. I recently decided it was time to upgrade to a true smart trainer and so got myself a Neo 2T. I came off my first session on the Neo 2T absolutely wrecked and put it down to poor recovery etc on my part but the same thing happened after my second session too so I started doing a bit of research. First thing I did was check my kit : no cross chaining, chain on smaller front cog and larger rear cog, good Ant+ connection (using Tacx Ant+ antena) etc. The I did a workout with TR connected to the Neo 2T and my Garmin Fenix watch connected to the Stages power meter (having done a zero reset). Having completed the workout I then collated the 2 sets of data in .tcx format and plotted them on a graph in Excel looking at the first 3 step ups in power as part of the warm up you can see that the Neo 2T is consistently under reporting the power compared with the Stages by 5-10% (I’ve tried to paste a screen shot below).
I completely accept that there will be a variance between measurements and was assuming/expecting 2-3% but 5-10% seems over the top. Looking through this post and others it seems I’m not alone in seeing this - has anyone figured out what causes it - given that there are just as many who don’t have the issue?