My highest recommendation goes to Exposure Lights, but let me step back first.
I had a Light & Motion Trail light which worked well. However, its battery life dropped to 10-20min when the temp dropped below 10ºC / 50ºF. I then went to a Bontrager ION 800 RT which did handle the cold but during a long ride (Grinduro Dolomites) with literally hours of heavy rain, it failed. (Once it dried out, it worked again and now sits in a drawer.) The L&M may have been 1000 lumens and the Bontrager was 800 lumens.
I needed something more waterproof, could handle temps, and I wanted more battery life than either the L&M or the Bontrager, which, under ideal conditions, gave around 75min of decent light. And, ideally, something with more lumens. I often ride in the dark (pre-dawn, rarely after dusk) and sometimes ride through tunnels. (The bluetooth option of the Bontrager – and I think the L&M light, too, but I could be wrong – was cool for automatically turning on and off the light under thick shading and in tunnels but this feature takes energy.) Another requirement was compatibility with a GoPro mount, which both the L&M and Bontrager also had.
I landed on Exposure Lights, particularly the Mk 14 Race (which I guess was replaced by their Mk 15 Race). It has a digital read-out telling me battery percentage, an auto-dim if you stop / are still for a while, and a bunch of different light settings. I use just two settings: max & max-low (not their term).
The Mk14 is 2100 lumens (far greater than my previous lights; the Mk 15 is 2200) and the battery life is awesome. A typical pre-dawn ride of 75min on max has 67-71% of the battery remaining. Yesterday, because of dense fog so the occasional car on the occasional pavement I rode and for walkers / cyclists I might encounter on trails, I had the light on “max-low” (the low setting for Program 1, the max setting) for the 4hrs and the battery still had something like 70% left (it’s rated for 12-13 hours at that setting).
They have smaller and larger sizes, but this size fit me. The spread is great, the brightness and whiteness is perfect (things aren’t washed out), and the battery life is superb. The digital indicator on the back for battery life to indicate the setting is also great. Besides the digital read, there’s a green light for the max and red for the max-law, which is toggled between using the single, easy to access and use even with a thickly gloved finger. Also, temperature, even down to -15C, has not meaningfully impacted the battery life.
In the pics, you can see ExposureLights uses a little extension doo-hicky, which gives an additional adjustment option and, more importantly, means you remove the light simply by pulling up on the red disc.
I do have the light pointed slightly more downward than I would if I was only running this light. Because I’m often riding in pitch black, or nearly so, I also ride with a helmet-mounted light: Lupine Piko, 1900 lumens on high. After a year the battery is about barely 1hr at high so now I toggle to medium, the remote for the headlight is attached to the side of my K-Edge (see the first pic above), when possible & carry a second battery. I like to see not just where I am going (the bar-mounted light), but where I want to go or simply to the side (hence the helmet-mount). The combination gives me great sight. This gives me plenty of light to see a spider at mouth height and distance to see obstacles Of course having the two lights at different intensities helps reveal and not washout or hide trail contours as I like my technical stuff where shocks would really come in handy.
Again, my rec is to look at ExposureLights. Solid, great battery, great beam, etc. You also most likely want to look at a trail light, whether ExposureLights or otherwise, because trail / MTB lights are more likely to have a wider spread.