When I started riding more seriously was in the 80’s, and LBS’s only ordered what they could sell. Sidi was all over the place, and some other Italian brands. To be honest, I was so discouraged by the choices, I thought I’d be stuck with crappy shoes. It WAS a joke how narrow the shoes I encountered were. ‘Who wears these?’ I kept wondering…
I had a pair of Scott’s (when I moved to the current house) that were hot as hell, but fit really extremely well. Eventually the sole completely delaminated from the upper and even using ‘heavy duty’ adhesive, they had to be tossed. I spent years in those shoes.
But Bontrager was a brand that I never encountered until Specialized started threatening the largest bike shop in the area, and they started bringing in Trek stuff on a part time basis. I LOVED the look of the Red XXX, and though expensive, fit well. I encountered Lake when I was looking for winter 2-bolt shoes, and they fit really well, but had never heard of that brand up until then.
Another brand that was wide enough was Shimano! I still have my first and best fitting SPD-2 bolt shoes, a hi-rise Shimano pair. They gave me hope. (They are hot too)
My feet are wide, but the biggest issue I face is I have ‘shockingly high’ arches too. (Like no cowboy boots for these feet unless they are customs
)
Why WAS I doing that to myself? To use clipless pedals, you need compatible shoes, and if the only pair you can find out of the dearth of choices available, you get the pair that fits the best out of the ones that don’t. (Interesting, your comment on Sidi. Back then I was told they were ‘the best shoe brand’. Hah!! Maybe they were back then, don’t know…
Trying to remember all the early shoes I had. Liked a Nike pair, might have had an Avocent pair, had a toe clip pair of shoes I tossed with those damn pedals when I went Look. My wife has had similar issues with finding shoes that fit. She really liked the Peloton mystery brand shoes, until one pair fell apart soon after she bought them. I tried to get her into the fizik shoes but she’d saner than I am. Figures that she isn’t going to pay that much for shoes she uses a couple of times a month.
The woman that ironically has thousands (a slight exaggeration) of pairs of shoes, and won’t get better riding shoes. When/where I started, I had such a limited choice.