i just purchased a Giant Revolt ADV 3 - which comes specced with an FSA Omega, 32/48 - right now i can’t see myself changing the crankset and am looking for a non pedal based power option … i know there are similar threads but most relate to a shimano crank …
wondering if anyone had any ideas … i am not DEAD set against pedal options as i have garmin v3’s for my road bike but thought i’d ask the knowledgeable folks on here for any options they have found
I just don’t think there is any crank arm or spider based version compatible with that crank.
I checked 4iiii, Stages, Power2Max, Rotor and couldn’t find any for the Omega. There are a few for the upper end FSA, but nothing for that one. I didn’t check SRM, but doubt they have one for a that crank.
The only options I’ve seen for you are pedal or PowerTap hub/wheel build with the old G3 disc.
So I think bike has a GRX400 FD. GRX has a slightly wider chainline that the typical Shimano Road FD’s. So for new cranks the easiest way to go (for compatibility, not necessarily finding it in stock) is to get a GRX crankset and a stages PM. I know Power2Max sells a spider based PM with GRX spacing but with new crank arms and every thing that would probably run you $800 while the stages route would be more like $500.
I have seen some people getting the GRX FD’s to play nice with the standard road spacing by bottoming out the limit screws. So that route would open up a few more options for PM’s but you would probably have to go to 50/34 gearing.
You could also just go for the FSA powerbox. They come in for like 500€ including the cranks. Propably will fit the BB too. Although I am not sure what gearing it´ll allow.
You can’t really reuse the rings from the FSA Crank. You can find a FSA Mega Exo crankarm PM out there, but why bother - it’ll be $500 and you have a poor quality FSA crank.
I’m not that technical, but if that was the same crank as was on my AL Topstone, I couldn’t find any option. I had two 4iiii left crank (ultegra on the “good” bike, 105 on the winter bike), so for me the cheapest option was a GRX crank set, and move the 105. Only clearance issue I had was the bottle cage on the underside of the downtube, which I didn’t use too often anyway.
If I was starting from scratch I’d be very tempted by the new Garmin pedals (or be waiting to see if any other options come out).