Short term gear fix (52/34 chain rings?)

I normally (and I am) running a 52/36 with an 11-28, which is perfect round here where a 1.5miles climb is a rarity. Actually its was fine for 5 months of lock down cycling back home in Fife (but probably nothing over 3-5miles of continuous climb 3% ave with the occasional 10-21% spikes at the extreme). I’m looking at booking a weeks winter holiday to some where warmer like Tenerife which has me thinking about my gearing. My chain is pretty new (less 400 miles) and the Fifer in me :joy: feels it would be a shame to shorten it for a week. I think I’ve got a 34t 4 bolt ring in my cupboard somewhere. If I was to swap out the current 36 to a 34 for one week would I see any significant problem with chain drop or shifting? Or is there something else I should consider?

I did that for a trip to the mountains in NC. Biggest issue was chain slack in the small / small gearing combo. But as long as I kept the chain on the 14t or above when in 34t ring, it was fine.

3 Likes

It’ll be fine. I typically run Shimano 52/34. The shifting could be smoother but I haven’t had a problem with slack and dropped the chain just as frequently as with a regular set up

2 Likes

I ran it for a good six months. I did drop the chain occasionally, enough that I added a chain catcher, but it’s entirely possibly I didn’t quite have it dialed in. And shifting from 34 to 52 was a little worse. I’d happily run it again if I had to for a trip or something, but I do prefer the shifting of “properly” matched Shimano chainrings.

1 Like

I run 52/34 with 11/32 in the back, I only ever have issues with chain slack when I get down to the 4th from smallest cog in the back. You’ll be fine as long as you are mindful of where your chain is :slight_smile:

2 Likes

While front shifting may suffer a bit from mismatched rings (especially under load), on rides featuring very long climbs where you may only front shift a handful of times for the entire ride, this may be quite acceptable. But in terrain featuring lots of short rolling climbs, this may be more of an issue.

1 Like